The Role of Spiritual Gifts

1 Corinthians 14:1-25

All too often we study this section without taking its context into account. As a result, many of us use this passage as a source of proof texts to back up one position or another regarding speaking in tongues. This is troubling on several levels, not the least of which is the fact that we tend to use the same passage to prove conflicting positions.

As you might suspect, when this happens, context is being ignored in favor of winning an argument. In this particular case, we are engaged in an argument that we shouldn’t even be participating in, no matter which side of it you are on.

As I mentioned at the beginning of this section, this is a study of 1 Corinthians, it is not a study of spiritual gifts as such. If you are interested in a study of spiritual gifts please see Your Spiritual Gifts Revealed which is available for free download on my website.

Let’s remember that chapter 14 is the third chapter in a section of the letter to Corinth that is discussing misunderstandings about spiritual gifts. It follows along from the previous chapter’s discussion of love as a contrast to the gifts themselves, as something that is eternal, while spiritual gifts are not. Paul has moved into a discussion here of the gifts in the context of the church assembly, and his overall point is that speaking in tongues really isn’t something that belongs in the worship assembly. He doesn’t say that because there is anything wrong with speaking in tongues; he says he himself speaks in tongues. Rather, his point is that it simply doesn’t edify the Body of Christ.

I realize that many would jump in here and assert that there is no longer any such thing as speaking in tongues… or prophecy, for that matter. I know this because that’s the way I learned it myself. If that happens to be your view, I would only say that Paul’s discussion here is in answer to an inquiry from the church in Corinth c. 55 AD: Context again!

I would also point out the lack of evidence from the New Testament for such an assertion.

Paul’s use of the contrast between speaking in tongues and prophecy is an interesting one, and it may be a bit confusing for some of us. That confusion would arise from a misunderstanding of what prophecy actually is. So often in our time prophecy is spoken of as though it was foretelling the future and nothing more. Yet this understanding is a mistake, for a prophet is one who brings a message from God to His people. Quite often in Scripture this message is one of correction in which God is telling His people that action is needed to correct an error of one kind or another. Certainly, that is case for most of the Major and Minor prophets of the Old Testament.

With this in mind, the contrast between speaking in tongues that we cannot understand is in sharp contrast with someone who brings a clear message from God to His people, and thus, Paul’s point is clearly made in these verses.

Notice that Paul wraps up his point by pointing out that should an unsaved person visit the worship assembly and be confronted by people who speak in an unintelligible manner, they would conclude that Christians were crazy, but if they heard a clear message from God they might well be brought to repentance and relationship with Christ.

That is the case Paul is making in this passage. It applies just as much today as it did then, and we will miss that critical point if we indulge ourselves by mining the text for ammunition to use in an unnecessary argument.

About Don Merritt

A long time teacher and writer, Don hopes to share his varied life's experiences in a different way with a Christian perspective.
This entry was posted in Bible and tagged , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to The Role of Spiritual Gifts

  1. Well said. Thanks for the insight!

  2. Matt Brumage says:

    Don, you are the first person I’ve read who interpreted the contrast of prophecy and tongues to mean Paul didn’t believe tongues belonged in worship. As I think about it, initially (i.e. without really researching it), I don’t agree because of Paul’s inclusion of tongues in the context of his description of orderly worship. Since I haven’t ever considered your position, I need to think that through some more perhaps. Maybe you could weigh in on why you think, if Paul included tongues in his description of orderly worship, he then concludes it shouldn’t be practiced in gatherings?

    Thank you for the entry, I now have something to chew on in what I thought was a familiar passage. There goes the rest of my day. Blessings upon you and yours!

    • Don Merritt says:

      Hey Matt!

      I really don’t like to reveal my little tricks in public view, but I will just this once… When I go through a book like this, I tend to approach the text as though I don’t really know what’s coming next. The whole object for me is that you would chew on a familiar text, get into the Word, and test your understanding. In this, I am probably a victim of my previous training as a Prof…

      There is a little clue in this post however, which is : “…speaking in tongues that we cannot understand…”

      In the orderly section, Paul mandates an interpreter so that we can understand – which was not the way the Corinthians had been doing things previously in their chaotic style of worship.

      So, you are right, but don’t let that keep you from chewing some more, since that’s the whole point of the exercise.

      • Matt Brumage says:

        Ah, got it! Sorry for “peeking behind the curtain”. Blessings!

        • Don Merritt says:

          One of the things I really like about this medium is that we can cover texts in pieces, so that we present the text as the first recipients heard them, without skipping to the end all the time. As they sat there and listened to letter progress, how did they react as Paul made his various points? Wouldn’t it be interesting to know… especially in chapter 15.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s